Internal Audit and Non-Performing Loans in Kazakhstan’s Banks: Results of a Panel Study 2015–2024

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26577/be201108426

Abstract

Purpose – this study examines the association between internal audit characteristics and credit risk in Kazakhstan’s commercial banks. The non-performing loan ratio (NPL) is the principal outcome; the return on assets (ROA) model is treated as an extension, and capital adequacy (CAR) is examined descriptively.

Methodology. The panel covers 13 commercial banks over 2015-2024 (130 bank-year observations). Internal audit is captured by organisational independence (IA_IND) and composite proxies for audit regularity (IA_FREQ) and for the scale, resources and authority of the function (IA_SIZE); total bank assets (Assets, KZT million) serve as a control. Pooled ordinary least squares (POLS), fixed-effects (FE) and random-effects (RE) models are compared; the Hausman, modified Wald and Wooldridge tests guide specification selection and error diagnostics, and robust standard errors are reported for the final RE model.

Originality and value. Proxies for internal audit characteristics are constructed from public reports, enabling their comparable description across banks and years and their comparison with bank financial indicators. The study identifies the limitations of public disclosures for assessing internal audit; the accuracy of the proxies depends on the completeness of public reporting.

Findings. In the final RE model with robust standard errors, total bank assets (Assets) are negatively and statistically significantly associated with the NPL ratio: a difference of KZT 1 trillion in assets corresponds to a difference in NPL of approximately -0.51 percentage points. The coefficients for IA_IND and IA_FREQ are negative but statistically insignificant, which does not imply the absence of an association. Overall, the associations between internal audit characteristics and NPL receive limited statistical support; the estimates describe statistical associations rather than a causal effect.

Keywords: internal audit; credit risk; non-performing loans; commercial banks; Kazakhstan; panel data.

Author Biographies

  • U. A. Shonayeva, Narxoz University, Almaty, Kazakhstan

    PhD student at Narxoz University (Almaty, Kazakhstan, e-mail: shonayevaulpan@gmail.com).

  • A. M. Nurgaliyeva, Narxoz University, Almaty, Kazakhstan

    Candidate of Economic Sciences, PhD, Research Professor of the Accounting and Audit Educational Programme, School of Economics and Management, Narxoz University (Almaty, Kazakhstan, e-mail: aliya_mn@mail.ru).

  • D. E. Mynbayeva, Q University, Almaty, Kazakhstan

    PhD, Associate Professor at the School of Business and Management, Q University (Almaty, Kazakhstan, e-mail: mde2000@mail.ru).

Published

2026-11-20

How to Cite

Internal Audit and Non-Performing Loans in Kazakhstan’s Banks: Results of a Panel Study 2015–2024. (2026). Journal of Economic Research & Business Administration, 158(4). https://doi.org/10.26577/be201108426